Showing posts with label revision. Show all posts
Showing posts with label revision. Show all posts
Wednesday, June 20, 2012
To Outline or Not to Outline
Dear readers and writers,
There's a never-ending argument among writers about outlining, with passionate advocates on both sides. One of my writer friends posted recently about how important an outline can be to connections, to underlying themes, to making sure no balls are dropped. My thought is this: If you can do it, yes, it can do all those things. I'm in the no-outline camp for my own writing. I have nothing against those who can do it. But when I outline, my writing resembles a sixth grade essay, not the kind of subtle, interesting prose I would enjoy reading myself. I need the element of surprise in drafting the fictional story to keep my interest high. Once I've constrained the spirits with an outline, the life has drained out of it and I can't write it any more.
So does that mean my fiction is un-connected, without persistent themes, and full of disconnected dropped balls that beg for catches and resolutions? Yes, in my SFD (refer to Anne Lamott for translation of first draft epithet). But that's okay, because during revision (which is really re-visioning the whole for me) I can rearrange, cut, add, stream in thematic references, and find and fix the dropped balls. That is a very different job for me than the writing itself. I suppose it is a lot less important and intrusive for the outliners, but I love the way it feels like working a jigsaw puzzle. I have all these pieces. How am I going to optimally fit them together into a complete story? Looking at the box is OK, but so is correcting the box. Some of my no-outline friends refer to this method as post-outlining. I must say it has things in common, but I do most of it in my head by reading and thinking, rather than making that outline on paper.
But whatever you do, the important thing is to connect the dots at some point during the process. Your payoff with an outline is efficiency. My payoff without is suspense (for me) and freshness (for readers). I think I also probe deeply into my characters in places where the story might not finally have to go, but where the depths enrich the development of that character. So while I cut out a lot, those pieces have contributed to the background in important ways.
Enjoy writing!
Cheers, Laura
Labels:
connections,
dropped balls,
enjoyment of writing,
fiction,
first draft,
freshness,
outlines,
post-outlining,
puzzle,
revision,
suspense,
theme
Thursday, May 31, 2012
Vinegar and Salt
Hi readers and writers,
When I write my first drafts, definitely to Anne Lamott's prescribed degree of non-excellence, I often reread them and wonder, "Where's the beef?" The thing I tend to leave out is the tension. One of my friends from many years ago once made a dish called Slum Gullion, essentially Beef Stroganoff with burger substituted for the steak. She forgot the vinegar and salt, and it was so bland we had decided never to use the recipe again until she reread it and realized what she had left out: the taste, the subtle items that make you want more so you can figure it out. My first drafts can be that way. The bones of the story are there, but the lines between them are all slack and there's nothing urgent about how things are connected. Revision is where I actually put together the motivation, the tension, the stress and write them into the story.
Adding tension sounds like there's no way it could work. Not true, though. It's implied there already, but in the written part, it's not featured. I just need to bring it out, show the dialog with subtext and conflicting desires, let the characters try to move the story towards their individual dreams. I often cut out text that is over-the-top descriptive or contains information in excess and replace it with these elements that ratchet up the stakes for the characters.
What are your revision strategies? Do you need to add tension, or do you concentrate on the beauty of the sentences, or do you add subplots?
cheers,
Laura
Image from Creative Commons/Wikipedia with thanks.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

